Examples of Metal Traditions Involving/Inspired by Emotional Arousal

Headbanging

Perhaps the most famous, common, and elementary example of emotional arousal theory at work as it pertains to heavy metal is the classic headbang. Humans have been moving our bodies to music in one way or another for as long as humans and music have existed- that much is nothing new. This practice is known as sensorimotor stimulation. (Repp 1) Headbanging to rock and metal music specifically, however, may be more than just a way to express general excitement and appreciation for the music. At the right is a video recording of one of the earliest documented instances of headbanging during a rock/metal show, featuring a Led Zeppelin concert from 1970. (Childers) The front row of the crowd (closest to the stage) can be seen headbanging, though admittedly not as ferociously as crowds in future years would, such as those in the accompanying clip of a 2008 Slipknot show. Note what song is being played in this clip, though: “Communication Breakdown,” a song about mixed messages in a relationship, confusion, and general mental distress- all common themes in hard rock and metal, styles pf which Led Zeppelin are undeniably progenitors. Banging and shaking one’s head can thus be seen as a gesture of identifying with the song’s lyrical themes- an effort to “shake out” the negativity and feelings of inadequacy or confusion from the song’s lyrics that resonate with the listener. In this sense, headbanging is not simply a way for listeners to keep time with a song, but a ritualistic release of negative emotions and anxieties about life and the world. In this example, the listener takes in a stimulus, it resonates with their emotions, and they act accordingly to release a physical response- textbook emotional arousal theory at work.

Crowd Surfing

A version of a classic “trust fall” taken to an extreme conclusion, crowd surfing is the practice of an individual being lifted up by their fellow concertgoers and being propelled across the crowd by said fellow concertgoers pushing and lifting their body forward, usually towards the front of the stage as to get a better view of the performers. There is always an associated risk of injury from being dropped/mishandled or having your pocket picked by those lifting you up, yet crowd surfing remains among the most popular metal traditions; I attended a Cannibal Corpse concert in September of 2025 and had to propel crowd surfers forward at a rate of several per minute lest I have my spine telescoped by a full-grown human falling on my head. Still, I felt honored to be a part of the practice, and it made apparent to me the purpose of this seemingly purely hedonistic practice. The act of crowd surfing is a way of expressing the feelings of freedom and camaraderie present in the metal community- another application of emotional arousal theory. Crowd surfers literally place themselves and their safety in the hands of their fellow metalheads in spite of the clear risks associated with the practice because of their faith in the community- a faith fostered by the community’s anti-judgement, pro-emotional arousal values. Further, crowdsurfing is often a way for disabled or otherwise mobility-restricted fans to get a better view of the performer; there’s no shortage of videos of fans in wheelchairs being surfed to the front row of the crowd, as seen in the example at left. What might seem like an annoying, imposing practice at first is actually an extremely positive way for metal crowds to express friendship with and trust in one another.

Disclaimer: This video contains some coarse language and may not be suitable for general audiences. It is used herein purely for illustrative purposes.

Citations

Childers, C. (2023, October 19). Who Originated Headbanging? Loudwire. https://loudwire.com/who-originated-headbanging/

Nickerson, C. (2022, May 13). Catharsis: Definition & Meaning (S. McLeod, Ed.). Simply Psychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/catharsis.html

Ragusa, P. (2021, August 19). Moshing: The Art and Consequences of One of the Most Celebrated Concert Dance Forms. Consequence of Sound. https://consequence.net/2021/08/moshing-history-essay/

Repp, B. H. (2005). Sensorimotor synchronization: A review of the tapping literature. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 12(6), 969–992. https://doi.org/10.3758/bf03206433

Wildberger, J., & Farreras, I. (2016). Helping behavior in heavy metal concerts. Modern Psychological Studies, 22(1), 11. https://scholar.utc.edu/mps/vol22/iss1/11/?utm_source=scholar.utc.edu%2Fmps%2Fvol22%2Fiss1%2F11&utm_medium=PDF&utm_campaign=PDFCoverPages

Video Credits

666peoples**t666. (2008, April 13). Corey Taylor - Best headbanger ever. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ENAN6JTQR0

Dave Danchuk. (2025, April 2). Why metal shows rule. Man in wheelchair crowd surfing at In Flames show in Vancouver. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-WCNZB-Z5jw

Led Zeppelin. (2007, October 15). Communication Breakdown (Live at Royal Albert Hall 1970) [Official Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KqF3J8DpEb4

Wyatt's Metal. (2023, July 13). The Mosh Pit: Beginner’s Guide. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvi2icL2WnU

Listen to some metal songs with themes of emotional arousal

Moshing

Originating in the 1970s hardcore punk scene but quickly spreading to metal and other genres, moshing describes a style of frenetic, violent dancing that usually involves swinging of the arms and legs as well as slamming into other nearby dancers with your body or elbows, usually conducted in a circular area of a crowd colloquially called the “mosh pit.” (Ragusa) If someone falls in a mosh pit due to particularly frenetic dancing or from an unexpected collision with another mosher, it is widely known that the rest of the pit is to cease moshing until the downed individual is helped up and is given a quick check to make sure they are unhurt in order to prevent trampling injuries. (Wildberger 1-2) Though mosh pits seem violent and antisocial, the truth is that they are a shining example of metalheads being emotionally grounded and prosocial. As I see it, one could liken it to a pair of martial artists sparring in order to improve their skills: yes, someone may get bruised up in the process, and the actual actions are violent, but it’s in service of a constructive practice meant to improve both participants’ skills as fighters and both parties gave their consent to be involved. Mosh pits are much the same, except instead of the purpose being to improve one’s skills, it’s to improve one’s emotional health. If you slammed into someone on the street as a way of channeling frustration or anger, they’d be well within their rights to knock your block off in self defense. In the mosh pit, however, all are on equal footing- everyone consented to be in the pit, (as there’s usually ample non-pit space for the rest of the crowd to stand if they are uninterested in moshing) everyone is enjoying the same music, and everyone is seeking an outlet to express their emotional arousals. By this logic, moshing is, in essence, a communal release of emotional arousal set to music to enhance and heighten the mood. This intersects with another sociological school of thought, catharsis theory, which states that humans often seek out simulacra of dangerous or undesirable situations in order to satisfy and release inner emotional turmoil; we seek out the sort of mock-brawl that a mosh pit becomes in order to quench our thirst for a real fight. (Nickerson) With both catharsis theory and emotional arousal theory in play, the mosh pit becomes the dominant sociological stage in which the many social contracts and traditions of the metal community play out.